Skip to content
The growth system: websites, Google and social
brilliant

Choosing a provider10 min readUpdated 1 November 2026

Checkatrade vs your
own website:
which wins more work
for tradespeople?

Checkatrade vs your own website: what each one gives a tradesperson, what it really costs, and how to use both.

In this guide
  1. Checkatrade vs your own website: the basic difference
  2. What a directory gives you
  3. What a directory costs, and what it hides
  4. What your own website gives you
  5. How to use both sensibly
  6. How to build trust without a directory badge
  7. Where we fit in
Checkatrade vs your own website: which wins more work for tradespeople?

Key takeaways

  • Directories such as Checkatrade, MyBuilder and Rated People rent you an audience. Your own website and Google profile are an audience you own.
  • The best plan for most tradespeople is both: a directory for quick leads, and your own site to turn Google searches and word of mouth into work you do not pay per lead for.
  • Judge any lead source by cost per job won, not cost per lead.

Checkatrade vs your own website:
the basic difference

A directory is like renting a stall in a busy market. Customers arrive already looking, and the directory vets members and shows reviews. But you share the stall with every other tradesperson, and you pay to stay there.

Your own website is like owning a shop. It takes longer to fill, but the customers who find you are yours. You do not pay a fee each time one calls.

What a directory gives you

  • Instant visibility. You appear in front of people who are searching right now.
  • Borrowed trust. Vetting and verified reviews help a stranger feel safe calling you.
  • A quick start. A new business can get calls within days.

What a directory costs, and what it hides

Fees differ between platforms and change over time, so check the current terms on each site before you sign up. Most charge a membership, a fee per lead, or both. The part that catches people out is the competition. The same enquiry may go to several tradespeople, so you are often racing to reply first and quoting against two or three others.

That squeezes prices. It also means you can pay for leads that never turn into jobs. Work out your real figure: add up what you spent last quarter, divide by the jobs you actually won, and compare that with other routes.

Judge every lead source by cost per job won, not cost per lead. A cheap lead that never converts is expensive.

What your own website gives you

The trade-off is time. A new website needs to be found, which comes from a complete Google Business Profile, reviews and a site built to convert. See what makes a website convert.

  • Customers who are yours. Their details, their reviews and their repeat business belong to you, not a platform.
  • Better-quality enquiries. People who found you through Google, a friend or a van sign often arrive already trusting you.
  • Lower cost over time. You pay for the site once a month, however many people call.
  • Control of your message. Your prices, your areas, your best jobs and your guarantees, in your words.

How to use both sensibly

  • Keep the directory while you build up. It covers the gaps while your site and Google profile grow.
  • Send every directory customer to your own channels afterwards. Ask them for a Google review and keep their details for repeat work and referrals.
  • Track where each job came from. After three months, you will know which source pays.
  • Shift effort towards what you own. As your website and profile bring in more calls, you can reduce what you spend on rented leads.

How to build trust without a directory badge

A directory badge is a shortcut to trust. You can replace it with proof of your own on your website:

  • Your trade accreditations and insurance, shown clearly, such as Gas Safe, NICEIC or a trade body. See the website checklist for tradespeople.
  • Genuine Google reviews, with your replies. See how to get more Google reviews.
  • Photos of real jobs, before and after, with the area they were done in.
  • A clear price guide and a plain-English description of how a job works.

Where we fit in

Our websites for tradespeople are built to do the job a directory does for you, so that more of your work comes through channels you own. Prices start from £149 a month, and you can see your free plan first.

Frequently asked questions

Is Checkatrade worth it for a small tradesperson?

It can be, particularly when you are starting out. Work out what you pay against the jobs you actually win. If the cost per job is high, shift effort towards your own website and Google profile.

Can I rank on Google without Checkatrade?

Yes. Many tradespeople get most of their work from Google through a complete Business Profile, reviews and a clear local website.

Should I cancel my directory membership when my site goes live?

Not straight away. Keep it while your own channels grow, track where jobs come from, and review it after a few months.

More questions? Browse all our FAQs.

Useful next: website and marketing glossary, practical checklists and the website ROI calculator.

Get the 12-point website launch checklist.

Open it straight away, and we will email you a copy and one practical tip a month. Unsubscribe whenever you like.

By signing up you agree to get our emails. See our privacy policy.

Next step

Ready to put this into practice?

See websites for tradespeople

Ready for more
customers?

Less hassle starts with your free plan: see it in 30 seconds, or book a quick call. No card needed to get started.

  • 30-day marketing guarantee
  • Live in 7 days
  • One fixed price